The Ongoing Battle Over Mauis Short Term Rental Rezonings

The debate over the future of apartment-zoned short-term rentals on Maui reached a critical juncture this week.

Following the passage of Ordinance 5909 (Bill 9)—which mandates the phase-out of transient vacation rentals (TVRs) on the historical Minatoya List by 2029 in West Maui and 2031 island-wide—the County established a legal pathway (Ordinance 6008) allowing eligible properties to apply for H-3 and H-4 Hotel Zoning to maintain short-term rental operations.

However, translating that legislation into individual parcel decisions has sparked intense discussion between housing advocates urging a return of inventory to local residents and condo owners seeking to protect long-standing property rights.

The Planning Commission’s Advisory Votes

In recent hearings, the Maui Planning Commission evaluated dozens of condo complexes seeking hotel zoning.

While the Planning Commission ultimately voted no on the majority of requested conversions, its findings serve as advisory recommendations. The ultimate authority to approve or deny hotel rezoning applications rests solely with the Maui County Council, which has until late November 2026 to review the recommendations and cast final votes.

County planning officials clarified that properties applying for hotel zoning generally fall into six main structural categories:

1. Variances: Properties operating under explicit, existing variances (such as Hale Kāʻanapali and Kūʻau Plaza).
2. Dedicated Timeshares: Fully timeshare-dedicated complexes like Maui Schooner in Kīhei and Hono Koa in West Maui.
3. Single-Owner Properties: Buildings with a single owner operating similarly to boutique hotels.
4. Mixed-Use Complexes: Properties combining timeshare units and transient vacation rentals, such as Maui Sunset, Kauhale Makai, and Maui Hill.
5. Leasehold Properties: Buildings with leasehold ownership structures, including Kāʻanapali Royal, Kuleana Resort, and Kanaʻi A Nalu.
6. Resort-Style Condominiums: High-density, amenity-rich complexes functioning operationally like hotels, such as Kamaʻole Sands, Papakea Resort, and Maui Eldorado.

Two Perspectives on Island Housing & Economy

The debate highlights two distinct viewpoints regarding Maui's community needs and financial realities:

• The Case for Housing Preservation: Housing advocates, including representatives from Lahaina Strong, emphasized the critical need for long-term residential housing. Proponents argued that upzoning apartment complexes into hotel districts permanently removes potential housing stock for local families, cautioning the County against converting residential neighborhoods into transient accommodations.
• The Case for Financial Viability & Property Rights: Property owners and HOA board members argued that many of these oceanfront, resort-style complexes are functionally unsuited or financially out of reach for traditional long-term housing. Owners of leasehold units noted that short-term rental revenue is often the primary mechanism offsetting high ground leases and maintenance fees. Banning TVR uses in those complexes, they warned, could lead to financial distress rather than affordable long-term options.

What Real Estate Buyers & Sellers Need to Know

For property owners, buyers, and investors navigating the current market, these legislative proceedings underline several key considerations:

As the Maui County Council prepares to deliberate on these advisory recommendations, staying informed on individual complex zoning designations is essential when evaluating property values, cash-flow models, and long-term ownership goals.

Your Trusted Maui Real Estate Partners

Navigating Maui’s evolving land-use regulations requires accurate, hyper-local guidance. Whether you are analyzing rental histories, reviewing complex zoning maps, or planning a purchase or sale, our team is dedicated to providing clear data and objective guidance every step of the way.

The Smith Team

Coldwell Banker Island Properties

Licensed in the State of Hawaiʻi

3750 Wailea Alanui Dr, Suite B35, Wailea, HI 96753

Direct: (808) 879-1991 | Web: www.mauihomebuyer.com

PC: Mauinow

Tags